Wheat Wrote WHAT?!

String and Life Blog-A-Venture


Get Email Delivery

Log in
December 20th, 2007 at 08:36 am

The Robin Hood Rationalization

It is year end and like all business folk, we are looking back over the year and seeing what and who have most impacted our business this year.

Personally, family health issues have kept us at home instead of “enjoying” the life of show gypsy, but life happens and you have to roll with it. Instead we have been working on new products and the development of retail & wholesale websites.

The second biggest impact on our business has been what some like to call infringement, but what is in reality the rampant stealing of intellectual property.

Our YARNandTHREAD businesses are heavily involved with the Design Community so tend to be publicly proactive regarding copyright and intellectual property issues.

Sooner or later in any On-Line group discussions, someone starts spouting what I call the

Robin Hood Rationalization

These are the most insidious of the offenders. And, once introduced to the discussion, It is also the point at which further discussion becomes pointless.

They have decided, (without ever checking on the facts) that because they disagree with a law that protects Intellectual Property, and because these laws only exist because of their lack of respect for anyone or anything that stands in the path of what they have decided they are entitled to…

They attempt to cloak their criminal activity by Rationalizing their behavior by saying the law ONLY protects “BIG CORPORATIONS” so they are only stealing from those bad nasty people.

Like Robin Hood, these Thieves, these Pattern Pirates,

believe it is okay to STEAL

Apparently without any thought or concerns for who might be hurt.

Recently one person ranted that their action was justified as an act of Civil Disobedience. She made mention o f the Boston Tea Party. I would respond that there is a vast difference between Civil Disobedience to protest an unjust governmental policy – be that policy about where to sit on the bus to Taxation without Representation.

In fact, the reference to the Boston Tea Party, an act having to do with Taxation and how that was
considered Robbery without at Gun, is used to justify a similar act, the Stealing of a livelihood from the individual who has worked to create the pattern, chart or instructions you are enjoying.

I submit that behavior has more in common with Machevelli than Robin Hood.

Ignoring the fact that without BIG CORPORATIONS with the Deep Pockets to defending their Coroporate interests, there would be no viable protections for the tiny Microscopic Business of the Needle & Fiber Arts Independent Self-Publishers to have any protection at all.

Next time, you download a copy that someone else is illegally offering

Next time, before you STEAL (not share) an illegal copy of a pattern or chart –

Next time you offer to make Counterfeit copy of a Pattern or Chart or other Intellectual Property

Ask yourself,
Do I really want to be a petty criminal?
Do I really want to teach others that Stealing is Okay?

Everyone loves the myth of Robin Hood, and we seem to live in a Machiavellian Society.

Yet, it that really who you want to be. When all is said and done, nothing more than a common thief?

3
  • 1

    I have a question for you – are crocheters worse at this sort of thing than knitters? Since I don’t hang out on any knit groups (I knot incredibly slowly) I don’t know ehat they discuss.
    But I belong to several online crochet groups and not a week goes by unless somebody is begging for cheap / free yarn. No, not because they have been some sort of household accident or some other tragedy. Just because they seem to think everybody has yarn and wants to give it away to them.
    Don’t get me wrong. I don’t mind pitching in hooks or yarn for somebody who is in a tight spot. All of us hit rough spots in life. I even like it better when the person thanks me. (You would be surprised how seldom that happens – or maybe you wouldn’t). But is this trait unique to crocheters?
    Just wondering…..

    blazelaflame on December 21st, 2007
  • 2

    Even Wheat would not be brave enough to say that any single group has a larger number of “takers”

    Fortunately I do not believe that to be true

    I would say it is not unique to any single craft niche

    There will always be takers and givers and they the takers will always find a way to rationalize their bad behavior.

    In the link section marked Worth Thinking About, you will see two articles more or less related.

    wheat on December 22nd, 2007
  • 3

    Good post. Bookmarked.

    Law News on August 14th, 2008

 

RSS feed for comments on this post | TrackBack URI

  • November 2017
    S M T W T F S
    « Jun    
     1234
    567891011
    12131415161718
    19202122232425
    2627282930  
  • Non-Standard Disclaimer

    Wheat Wrote WHAT !?!Assumes ONLY YOU can properly and completely perform the necessary due diligence to determine your course of action in life or business - ALL article, like all on this blog, are a starting point, not the last word by any means. While I hope it is worth more, its value is exactly the same as what you paid for it – no dollars.
    Wheat Wrote WHAT !?! began as a place to express opinions strongly held or silly without everyone getting their panties in a twist assuming those opinions to be a personal attack because they lack the ability to discern between discussing the point and flaming a person.
    Wheat Wrote WHAT !?! is also where Wheat writes about products she uses and occasionally mentions ones best avoided. These may also but not always and not surprisingly are sold at ItsAllJustString,com
    Wheat Wrote WHAT !?! is also where she expresses sometimes controversial opinions about just about anthing so please expect the occastion rant.
    Wheat Wrote WHAT !?! welcome your comments - just remember - we want ot discuss the point not the person unless they are public usually political person.
    Wheat Wrote WHAT !?! is where Wheat writes primarily about things she uses and sells thru ItsAllJustString,com
    Wheat Wrote WHAT !?! blogamentries are based on personal experience and opinon. Your experience and opinion may differ. "what works for wheat may not work for you"
    © 2002-Infinity Wheat Wrote WHAT !?!
    WheatCarr.com
  • Recent Posts

  • Recent Comments

  • Categories

  • Archives

  • Pages

  • Meta

>/font>